Prepaid Phone Plans & Providers | Customer Ratings – Canstar Blue

Prepaid Phone Plans & Providers

Advertisement

Review and compare prepaid phone plan providers Skinny Mobile, Warehouse Mobile, 2degrees, Spark and Vodafone on value for money, customer service, accessibility, billing, network coverage and overall satisfaction.

See Our Ratings Methodology

Most Satisfied Customers | Skinny Mobile

Skinny Mobile has topped Canstar Blue’s prepaid phone plan ratings for the fourth year in a row, once again standing out in key areas like customer service and overall satisfaction.

Skinny Mobile weighs in with fourth prepaid win

If you’re on a budget, or don’t like having to mess around with costly contracts and bundled phone plans, a prepaid plan can work out to be great value. They differ from other phone plans in that you pay first, load credit and then you can either top up only when you need to or set it to ‘auto recharge’. This can work out to be pretty cost-effective and is a great option to prevent bill shock.

Furthermore, if you’re happy with your current handset and believe it’s just your service provider that needs an upgrade, then a prepay deal can work out to be a fuss-free option. Prepaid options are mostly bring-your-own-device or ‘BYOD’ so there are no costly or lengthy phone contracts.

However, not all prepaid plan providers are made equal. So, which are doing the best job by their customers? To find out, Canstar Blue surveyed more than 2,000 prepaid phone users and asked them to rate their service provider on important factors such as network coverage, customer service and value for money.

New Zealand’s three most prominent prepaid service providers featured in the results, as well as two relative upstarts – Skinny Mobile and Warehouse Mobile. However, it was one of these smaller carriers that continues to impress most, with Skinny Mobile achieving a five-star review for overall satisfaction, in addition to most other research categories. Another notable rating saw Warehouse Mobile earn five stars on value for money – the only telco here to do so.

All in all, it’s the fourth year in a row that Skinny Mobile has taken out top spot in our ratings. Warehouse Mobile rated four stars overall, while 2degrees, Spark and Vodafone brought in the rear with three stars for overall satisfaction. This may signify a shift in the mobile market, but to help you find the best deal for your needs, here is an overview of what the five providers in our ratings have on offer.

Prepaid Phone Plans Compared

As our need for data has grown, so too has the prepaid mobile plan market. There are quite a few providers out there, with the biggest five in our survey mentioned below. Note that plans can and do change all the time, so it also pays to check with the provider you’re interested in switching to.

Skinny Mobile Prepaid Plans

Skinny has four simple prepaid phone plans, with each lasting for 28 days before you need to recharge. Plans generally include some modicum of calls and texts, as well as data. Calls and texts to Australia are usually also included. Plans are as follows:

  • $9 – 100 minutes, 250MB data
  • $16 – 200 minutes, 1.25GB data
  • $26 – 300 minutes, 2.5GB data
  • $46 – Unlimited minutes, 10GB data

A few weekly recharges are also available, starting from just $4. All of Skinny’s 28-day plans come with unlimited texts, and all but the cheapest feature rollover minutes and data. Skinny achieved top results in most research categories, except for value for money where it achieved four.

Warehouse Mobile Prepaid Plans

You may not have heard of Warehouse Mobile, but you might want to zip it up and listen. Warehouse offers prepaid plans quite unlike anything in the market, as all are billed over 31 days – instead of the usual 28 and all come with 120 call minutes and unlimited texts, with the option to add on more. Plans are:

  • $12 – 500MB data
  • $16 – 1.25GB data
  • $38 – 5GB data

Additional packs can be purchased, such as unlimited calls for an extra $4 and an additional 500MB data also for $4. This means that you can customise your plan to suit your needs. You can simply text codes to Warehouse Mobile to get the extra credit, or purchase through the app. Warehouse Mobile scored four stars overall, but notably achieved five stars in value for money.

2degrees Prepaid Plans

2degrees logo

2degrees offers four distinct ‘Carryover Combo’ prepaid plans, meaning credit rolls over into the next month if left unused. All come with unlimited texts to NZ and Australia and all but the cheapest come with 200 call minutes to both NZ and our friends across the ditch. Plans are as follows:

  • $9 – 50 call minutes, 250MB data
  • $19 – 1.25GB data
  • $29 – 2.5GB data
  • $49 – 10GB data

Additional packs can also be purchased from just $3. International talk minutes can also be purchased from $10 and this includes over 20 destinations. Unlimited national calls can also be purchased for $12. 2Degrees scored three stars overall and for most other categories, except for customer service where it achieved four stars.

Spark Prepaid Plans

spark_logo

As NZ’s largest telco, Spark understandably has some competitive prepaid plans. There are three in total, and all come with unlimited texts and rollover data and talk. Plans are as follows:

  • $19 – 200 minutes, 1.25GB data
  • $29 – 300 minutes, 2GB data
  • $49 – 500 minutes, 4GB data

There are also data-only SIM cards, starting at $20 for 1.5GB plus 1GB for social media. Plans can also make use of the extensive Spark Wi-Fi network, tapping in when necessary. Bonuses also include 50% off Spotify Premium plus other goodies from time to time. Spark was rated three stars overall but did achieve four stars for network coverage.

Vodafone Prepaid Plans

vodafone_logo

Rounding out the list is Vodafone, which is a bit different to the rest. It offers three prepaid plans, which doesn’t sound like much until you consider one is customisable, meaning there are potentially hundreds of different call/text/data combos you can create. Other plans are as follows:

  • $19 – 200 minutes, 1.25GB data
  • $29 – 300 minutes, 2GB data

Data and minutes carry over, while plans come with unlimited texts as standard. As for the custom plan, 2GB data, 200 minutes and unlimited texts will cost you $27 every 28 days. All plans come with a 28-day term. All in all, Vodafone scored three stars overall and for every other research category.

How are Kiwis using their mobile phones?


Smartphones have an increasing presence in our lives, with many users in our latest survey admitting to some rather… worrying habits. Aside from the few listed above, 17 per cent also admitted to using their phone while driving, and not with handsfree!

  • More than a third also said they use their phone more than their computer or laptop.

Smartphones are well and good, but our appetite for data has grown and a plan that’s hot one year may not be the next. So, where can you find good value, and what are the major providers offering?

Should I get a prepaid plan?

If you’re making the jump from a phone on a monthly contract – maybe your contract is up or you’re just shopping around – then it’s important to consider the advantages and disadvantages of prepaid.

Prepaid phone plans can be great for casual phone users or those looking to rein in their mobile phone expenditure. Often with phones on a contract, you are paying hefty monthly bills – both for the phone itself and for your selected package of data, calls and texts. These plans can exceed $100 per month! In addition, you sometimes need to pay at least some of the phone off outright – so your first month can be very expensive indeed.

  • Prepaid is generally a much more budget-friendly option for the flexible and casual phone user, as you can shop around for a cheap deal, there are no contracts, and you don’t have to recharge every month if you so desire.

With this flexibility, you only pay for what you use. With phones on a monthly contract, you are generally locked into the same amount of data, calls and texts for the life of your contract, often 24 months. A lot can change in two years and chances are that at some stage, you either won’t be using your entire plan, or using too much.

But what can be an advantage, can also be a disadvantage. If you run out of credit, it can be annoying to have to consciously buy more unless you set it up to ‘auto recharge’. Alternatively, phones on a contract allow you to ‘set and forget’, which is convenient but can also prove costly as a lot of these contracts are for 24 months, meaning you could miss out on improved deals later on.

Whichever way you decide to go, it pays to shop around and regularly compare offers from different service providers. Skinny Mobile is the smaller operator tackling the big guys, and seems to represent good value for money on prepaid plans. But to find what’s right for you, keep an eye on the market for latest deals and you’re sure to find a plan for your specific needs.

Compare Phone Plan Providers

Frequently asked questions

Canstar Blue commissioned I-view to survey 5,000 New Zealand adults across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have an active pre-paid phone plan and pay the bill – in this case, 2,686 people.

Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then alphabetically. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.

Latest Phone & Internet articles

Fibre rollout: What is Ultra-Fast Broadband Unbundling?

Ultra-Fast Broadband (UFB) “unbundling” has been in the news of late – and, as rollout of the fibre network continues around New Zealand, consumers may be wondering what this will ultimately mean when it comes …

– Read more

The Best Shows on Lightbox NZ

For the most entertaining, thrilling and compelling programmes, streaming service Lightbox NZ has arguably the best on offer. While you might have to rent movies on Lightbox, it still offers plenty of award-winning television series …

– Read more

The Best Shows to Watch on Netflix NZ

It’s the end of Daylight Savings. The days are getting shorter. The rain is more frequent and the temperature is cooler. If any of this makes you feel down, then you clearly are not watching …

– Read more

No Contract Broadband Plans NZ

We Kiwis love a good deal, and the prospect of freedom and flexibility. This is especially the case of broadband plans. Internet is one of those utilities that it’s easy to pay too much for …

– Read more

The 5G Mobile Future: What can we expect?

Firmly entrenched in the age of the smartphone, and amid the continued evolution of the Internet of Things (IoT), the fast-approaching rollout of 5G wireless networks is poised to usher in the next phase of …

– Read more
Advertisement